II When settlement agreements are used

When settlement is proposed – understanding the real situation

You’re called into a quiet meeting. Your manager says she wants to talk “off the record” about your future.

You sit down. She hesitates, then says it.

“You’re underperforming. We’d rather avoid a process… what if we agree this exit package?”

She slides a document across the table. The cover sheet reads “Settlement Agreement”.

Your sales figures haven’t gone through the roof, they might even be trending downwards. So, you knew this wasn’t a conversation about making you “employee of the month.” But still, where’s the pep talk? Are they not even going to try some performance improvement or support? Why is no one even pretending to fix things? What exactly is happening here?

This guide is here to cut through the fog. Not with legal jargon, but with practical insight. It won’t make you an employment law expert. But it will help you understand the lie of the land:

  • Why your employer is doing this now

  • What protections they’re relying on

  • What pressure tactics are allowed (and what crosses a line)

  • What happens if you don’t sign

  • How you can keep your options open

Once you know the landscape, the document in front of you stops being something to fear and becomes what it really is: a proposal. And proposals can be questioned, countered, improved….or even walked away from.

So, before you sign anything, step back. Read the situation.

Let’s get into it…

Common situations where settlement agreements are used

  • Non-dispute situations

    Used where there is no grievance or legal claim. Employers are usually managing risk, restructuring, or seeking a clean exit rather than alleging fault.

    No formal dispute

  • Dispute situations

    Used where a grievance, discrimination issue, or whistleblowing concern has arisen. Employers are seeking to resolve legal and reputational risk early.

    A dispute has arisen

How employers think about settlement agreements

  • Why employers push for early settlement

    Employers often prefer to resolve matters early to control cost, avoid escalation, and limit management time and disruption. An early settlement is usually about certainty and risk management, not blame.

    Employer timescale

  • How employers calculate settlement offers

    Settlement offers are usually based on legal risk, potential cost exposure, and how likely a dispute is to escalate. The starting figure is rarely the maximum an employer is willing to pay.

    Employer calculation

Key takeaways: use of settlement agreements

5

6

Settlement agreements are often proposed before any formal dispute exists.

1

Being offered a settlement agreement does not mean you have done something wrong.

2

Employers usually act early to control risk, cost, and uncertainty.

3

The timing of an offer is about leverage and control, not blame.

4

The first offer is rarely the employer’s best or final position.

A settlement agreement is a proposal and does not have to be accepted.

Next section